Project:
Accommodating
the Urban Informal Sector in the Public Policy Process: A Case Study of
Street Enterprises in Bandung Metropolitan Region (BMR), Indonesia
EDI SUHARTO
2003 International Policy Fellow
The work during the first half of the fellowship year deals with the
refinement of project proposal and the completion of data collection
followed by writing a preliminary draft research paper.
1. Between
February and March 2003, I have refined project proposal. On
March 3-14, I attended the first seminar series in Budapest.
During this seminar, I was involved in important training
programmes focusing on issues of different components of policy
process, policy solution alternatives, policy analysis,
structure and strategies of think thanks in the US, Western
Europe and Central European countries. During this seminar, I
have also presented my project proposal to other IPF fellow
working on similar topics as well as to the working group
mentors. Based on discussions with group mentors, especially
with Andrew Cartwright, my project title is slightly changed
into “Integrating the Urban Informal Sector in the Public Policy
Process: A Study of Street Enterprises in Bandung Metropolitan
Region (BMR), Indonesia”. The term “accommodating” in the
previous title has been changed into the term “integrating”. The
project will come up with policy options that can be categorised
into three general approaches, such as “regulating”,
“accommodating”, and “curtailing”. The term “integrating”
incorporates these three meaning. |
2. Back from the seminar,
between March and April, I then wrote literature review to
understanding characteristics of street enterprises and policy
stances toward them. The theoretical considerations discussed in
this section cover the definition of the urban informal sector
and street enterprises, theoretical and policy perspectives on
the urban informal sector, models of policy options dealing with
street businesses, and locational decisions of the urban
informal sector. During this period I have contacted and sent
the project proposal to Tom Timar and Dedem Ruchlia, my
individual mentors, by email and direct visits respectively. I
have also written a paper on “Discovering the Urban Informal
Sector: A Literature Study” for Scientific Journal of Social
Work, Bandung School of Social Welfare, Volume 2, Number 2 and
will be published on August 2003. |
3. Attending seminar and
public debate on “Street Traders in Bandung: Issues and Policy
Alternatives”, in Bandung Institute of Technology (ITB) on 26
April. In this seminar, attended by different policy makers from
Regional Development Planning Agency (Bappeda) and Local
Government Offices (Pemda), academia, and street enterprise
operators, I presented my paper on “The Street Enterprises in
Bandung”. Based on my PhD thesis, the paper concerns with
characteristics of street enterprises in Bandung and possible
approaches to integrate them into the city master plan.
|
4. On May, my work focused on
the development of research methods, especially on generating
research parameters and instruments for data collections. The
methods of data collection that have been developed include a
questionnaire, interview guide, observation checklist and
document study checklist. The focus of inquiry included in these
research instruments were developed on the basis of research
parameters and indicators concerning (a) characteristics of
street enterprises, such as business profiles of street
enterprises, social and economic determinants of street vending
activities, and factors influencing the selection of worksites
of the street traders in the urban space economy, and (b)
existing policy measures relating to the operation of street
enterprises, such as approaches of the measures, problems and
implementation patterns, stakeholders (advocates, opponents,
decision-makers) involved, and participation and communication
procedures in policy-making |
5. On June 2 – 14, I attended
second seminar in Budapest. In this seminar, I received inputs
from the training focused on issues of different aspects of
policy process, effective policy advocacy, kinds of capacity
needed for achieving professional policy making process, roles
of policy analysts and policy advocates. I have also got
influential feedbacks from other IPF fellows working on similar
issues as well as from my working group mentors when I presented
and discussed my preliminary project results to them.
|
6. Fieldwork was conducted
between June and July followed by data analysis and writing
preliminary report of the research paper. Assisting by ten data
collectors, the data collection was done in two areas of Bandung,
namely Municipality (Kotamadya) and District (Kabupaten). Within
these two regions, four specific research sites were selected on
the basis of the agglomeration of the street enterprises:
street, market, commercial complex, and public transport
station. |
My work plan for the next months
would focus on conducting in-depth interviews with street
traders and policy makers. This work will then be followed by
seminars in Bandung to disseminate research findings to policy
stakeholders and generate policy issues and options with them.
Therefore, draft policy paper is not ready to be uploaded to my
WebPages. As stated in the project schedule, these seminars are
previously planned to do on November. In order to have ideas
from stakeholders concerning research findings and policy
options, however, it will be conducted earlier, hopefully
between August and September. |
|